Free shipping on online orders over $75 to the continental U.S

Pellet Stove vs Wood Stove: Which Should You Choose for Your Home?

Pellet Stove vs Wood Stove: Which Should You Choose for Your Home?

Posted on January 30, 2024 by
Posted in FAQ, General

Pellet Stoves vs Wood Stoves: A Comparison

Are you in search of an efficient way to keep your home cozy during the cold months without incurring hefty heating bills? Consider opting for a pellet stove or a wood stoveThese stoves use traditional heating methods, either by burning logs or wood pellets.

In this article, the experts at Earth Sense Energy Systems are going to review and compare the pros and cons of wood burning stoves and pellet stoves to decide which one is right for your home heating needs. Let’s talk about pellet vs wood stoves!


Fuel Types

Pellet Stoves

Pellet stoves operate using wood pellets, which are manufactured from recycled wood waste. These pellets are a sustainable fuel source, presenting an eco-friendlier alternative to non-renewable fuels.

Wood Stoves

In contrast, heating with wood stoves involves the process of burning seasoned firewood. Like wood pellets, firewood is a renewable resource, making it a greener choice compared to fossil fuels. For those who enjoy the traditional feel of a crackling fire, wood stoves are an attractive option.

Verdict

If the charm of a traditional fire entices you, opt for a wood stove. However, for a quieter and more subtle flame, a pellet stove is ideal.


Heat Output

Pellet Stoves

Pellet stoves are known for delivering even heat. The heat output varies based on pellet quality and stove design, but these stoves typically maintain consistent warmth. Many come with programmable thermostats for temperature control.

Wood Stoves

Wood stoves excel in heating power. Although pellet stoves usually have a lower BTU rating, wood stoves can reach over 100,000 BTUs. The heat output of wood stoves depends on the amount and moisture content of the logs.

Verdict

The heat output of both pellet and wood stoves is excellent, however, it will all come down to which model of stove you’ve chosen. Talk with the staff at Earth Sense to see which pellet or wood stove is right for you!


Inserts vs Freestanding Models

Pellet Stoves

Pellet stoves are available as either inserts, perfect for converting underutilized fireplaces, or as freestanding units for more flexibility in placement.

Wood Stoves

Similarly, wood stoves are offered in both insert and freestanding models, providing options for homes with or without existing fireplaces.

Verdict

Both pellet and wood stoves offer inserts and freestanding models to make your home appealing. Opting for an insert model, is particularly appealing for homes with an underutilized traditional fireplace. For homes without a fireplace or for those seeking more flexibility in the placement of the stove, freestanding models of pellet stoves and wood stoves are an excellent choice.

Read More: 5 Pellet Stove Care Tips to Know


Fuel Storage

Pellet Stoves

Fueling a pellet stove requires the use of wood pellets. Wood pellets are available in packaged bags, making it a simple process of opening these packages and loading the pellets into the stove. However, it’s worth noting that wood pellets typically come in 20 or 40-pound bags, which may be heavy to carry.

Wood Stoves

Operating a wood burning stove necessitates a substantial supply of firewood, which is bulky and demands considerable outdoor storage space. Additionally, significant effort is required in splitting and transporting the firewood indoors for stove fueling.

Verdict

It’s easier to manage bags of wood pellets instead of a bulky supply of firewood. However, it will come down to a matter of preference and comfortability when dealing with pellets vs firewood. When in doubt, please talk with the experts at Earth Sense.


Ash & Emission Production

Pellet Stoves

Pellet stoves are an eco-friendly option, since they produce less ash compared to wood stoves, which in turn, also helps to simply cleaning. They are also more environmentally friendly, emitting fewer pollutants.

Wood Stoves

While wood stoves require more frequent ash removal when compared with pellet stoves, they too are more eco-friendly than fossil fuel heating systems.

Verdict

Regular maintenance, including ash removal, is essential for both wood burning and pellet stoves to ensure cleanliness and prevent rust. However, pellet stoves have an advantage as they produce significantly less ash than wood stoves, simplifying the cleaning process.

While both stove types are more eco-friendly compared to fossil fuel-based heating systems, pellet stoves emit fewer pollutants than wood stoves, making them a more environmentally considerate option.


Stove Parts & Lifespan

Pellet Stoves

Pellet stoves are equipped with various electrical parts, including switches, fans, and motors. The presence of more electrical components means there are more chances for malfunctions and operational issues. As a result, pellet stoves typically have a shorter lifespan and may need more repairs compared to wood stoves.

Wood Stoves

Wood stoves operate without electricity and have fewer parts that could fail, often lasting longer than pellet stoves. In addition, wood burning stoves can continue to provide heat even when there is no power.

Verdict

The average lifespan of a wood stove ranges from 20 to 25 years, while a pellet stove generally lasts between 15 and 20 years. Additionally, since pellet stoves rely on electricity, they will cease functioning during power outages. Since wood stoves don’t rely on power, a wood stove provides a slight advantage over wood stoves.

Read More: Guide to Pellet Stove Parts


Overall Cost

Pellet Stoves

While initial costs can be high, pellet stoves often have lower installation costs due to simpler venting systems.

Wood Stoves

Wood stoves may require a more expensive insulated chimney system, increasing the overall installation cost.

Verdict

Initially, some pellet stoves may appear more expensive than wood stoves. However, when considering installation expenses, the overall cost can balance out. Wood stoves typically require an insulated chimney system, which must extend beyond the roof’s peak, adding to the installation cost.

Conversely, many pellet stoves can utilize a simpler direct-vent system, which is generally less costly to install than an insulated chimney system. Therefore, the total installation expense for a pellet stove often turns out to be more economical.

Read More: Take a Look at the Top 5 Pellet Stove Reviews!


Why Choose Us for Wood & Pellet Stoves?

When choosing between pellet and wood stoves, key factors to consider include fuel types, heat output, model options, ash and emission production, stove parts, and more.

Pellet stoves, running on wood pellet fuel, offer even heat distribution, simpler maintenance, and lower emissions, making them an eco-friendly and efficient choice. Check out our article on pellet storage tips here.

Wood stoves offer customers the beauty of burning seasoned firewood, while also providing a traditional heating experience with higher heating power and a longer lifespan but require more maintenance and have higher emissions.

When comparing wood and pellet stoves, each type of stove has its advantages in terms of installation costs and fuel storage needs.

Read More: Getting Your Pellet Stove Ready for Winter


 

Contact Earth Sense Today!

If you’re looking to make an informed decision about pellet or wood stoves, Earth Sense Energy Systems is an ideal online destination! We offer a wide range of high-quality pellet and wood stoves, along with a selection of wood pellets and stove parts to suit various needs and preferences.

Our commitment to excellence extends to providing prompt and reliable customer service, ensuring that every customer receives the support and expertise they need for a comfortable and efficient home heating solution. Earth Sense Energy Systems is your go-to source for all your pellet and wood stove needs. Contact our team today!

 

Further Reading: Freedom Pellet Stove Review

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *